Redwall Wiki Clone - User contributions [en]

User blog comment:Robinfeather/Essay: How large is Redwall Abbey?/@comment-24.136.170.154-20100214231726

2010-02-14T23:17:27Z

24.136.170.154: started new page.

I always thought of the animals human size. I always scaled down the larger ones (except occasionally with some badgers. I like to imagine Boar the fighter HUGE) and put objects such as trees and buildings at human size. But I'm impressed you did all that math just to get a rough size estimate, good job!

User blog comment:Shieldmaiden/Essay:Rebuttal to Good VS. Evil/@comment-24.136.170.154-20100214023814

2010-02-14T02:38:14Z

24.136.170.154: started new page.

Good points, but I don't think you can "inherit" the ability to use swords. I mean, some people may just be naturally good with them, as the case with Triss may be, but inheriting all skill she needed?
In Mossflower, Martin was a good warrior. But he did not inherit it from Luke. Like above it may run in the family, but I think he said something along the lines of this.
(Not direct quotations)
"As soon as I was tall enough to lift my fathers sword, I learned how to use it."
And,
"One time, my father was injured and I had to defend our cave. I remember all summer fighting off sea rats while my father sat inside the cave entrance, preparing our food and calling advice to me!"

So he admits he was trained and got advice. Later he was taught by Boar the Fighter. So yeah.... I should just get an account at this point.

User blog comment:Zoso159/Iowa represents Redwall (a retributal)/@comment-24.136.170.154-20100213003442

2010-02-13T00:34:43Z

24.136.170.154: started new page.

Question: Was the claymore shaped like a saber or a broadsword? (Yeah, odd but I'm curious.)
And it sounded pretty cool.

User blog comment:Martin2/Essay:Is Madd from Taggerung Fwirl's dead mother?(Rebuttal)/@comment-24.136.170.154-20100213002805

2010-02-13T00:28:05Z

24.136.170.154: started new page.

(This is the same person as below)
Also, I don't want to start an argument. Its a work of fiction and it gives you something the debate about.

User blog comment:Martin2/Essay:Is Madd from Taggerung Fwirl's dead mother?(Rebuttal)/@comment-24.136.170.154-20100213002408

2010-02-13T00:24:08Z

24.136.170.154: started new page.

Hmm a few issues with this. I will list them by the numbers.
1 and 2: Yes, a coincidence is possible but I think the author would have realized this.
4: it never said the log had holes.
5: true, but lying very still could mean unconscious as well.
6: If Madd had a deep head wound and was lying very still, how would they have known? Vermin aren't known for being very bright. Yes, foxes are generally smarter but if they have a nice strong squirrel slave, why check one that looks dead?
Last point, Brian Jacques never said she was... but he never said she wasn't.
In any event, you made some good points. Well done.

User blog comment:D2r/Unanswered Questions of Redwall/@comment-24.136.170.154-20100213001210

2010-02-13T00:12:11Z

24.136.170.154: started new page.

Hmm... I think the bread might be made of ground acorns and such. That doesn't answer where it was ground up but I think you can make something bread like from acorns.

User blog comment:LordTBT/News:"The Redwall Experience" prepares for "Sable Quean" release/@comment-24.136.170.154-20100122152506

2010-01-22T15:25:06Z

24.136.170.154: started new page.

I got Gonff the mouse thief! it actually fit rather well.

User blog comment:LordTBT/News:Iowa represents for Redwall/@comment-24.136.170.154-20100119214443

2010-01-19T21:44:43Z

24.136.170.154: started new page.

That sounds great.. more like a medieval demonstration with Redwall thrown in. Still great though. To bad I live to far away, ahh well.

User blog comment:Barkjon/After Redwall/@comment-24.136.170.154-20100114141657

2010-01-14T14:16:57Z

24.136.170.154: started new page.

Interesting.... a little too fast but could prove good. Nice job.

User blog comment:LordTBT/News:"The Sable Quean" promotional trailer/@comment-24.136.170.154-20100114140829

2010-01-14T14:08:30Z

24.136.170.154: started new page.

Hmm.... well its interesting. They could have maybe added music to make it flow a little better but still interesting. It looks like we have a hare main character which should be fun.

User blog comment:Ferretmaiden/Zaroc book 1. the beginning/@comment-24.136.170.154-20091215034502

2009-12-15T03:45:02Z

24.136.170.154: started new page.

hm... your chapters are a bit short but its pretty good. Semi happy endings are good and please write more when ye' get the time

User blog comment:Ferretmaiden/Jax and Felldoh: Forever Young/@comment-24.136.170.154-20091211152812

2009-12-11T15:28:13Z

24.136.170.154: started new page.

Please write more! Felldo is one of my all time favorite characters.

And actually, Nelvana made the Redwall tv series, it just aired on PBS.

Back on topic, it looks really good. Hope you write more, God bless.