https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/api.php?action=feedcontributions&feedformat=atom&user=74.181.47.0%2F24 2026-11-13T13:10:00Z User contributions MediaWiki 1.46.2 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=Essay:Lame_Villain_Deaths&diff=8500 2009-02-20T22:46:57Z

<p>74.181.47.169: </p> <hr /> <div>{{Essay|Lord Stonepaw}}<br /> As I've read the books of Redwall, (I am currently in the process of reading [[The Legend of Luke]]), I have noticed some really strange and silly deaths. Most notable to me was the death of [[Klitch]]. I read the book a while ago, but for what I remember, he did know about the water's poisoning. The death of [[Ublaz Mad Eyes]] I noticed was very very incomplete. [[Grath Longfletch]] had all right to kill him, but [[Martin II]] I thought was a decent enough choice, too, but ''stepping'' on a snake? No. Next, the death of [[Slagar the Cruel]] was also incomplete. Falling down a well was a little bit unexpected, and some characters had more right to kill him, such as [[Matthias]] in the place of [[Mattimeo]] and [[Orlando the Axe|Orlando]] in the place of [[Auma]]. Next, [[Gabool the Wild]]'s killer did not deserve that right. [[Rawnblade Widestripe]] throwing a [[Skrabblag|scorpion]] at him was a little daft, and I think [[Mariel Gullwhacker|Mariel]] or [[Joseph the Bellmaker|Joseph]] deserved to kill him. Finally, [[Mokkan]]'s death was a little bit strange in manner, but at least [[Nettlebud]] had some right. It would have been better had the spear of killed Mokkan directly, and I thought that the [[Marlfoxes#Teeth of the Deeps|Teeth of the Deeps]] had all eaten each other. That is my input on lame deaths.<br /> <br /> [[Category:Essays]]</div>

74.181.47.169