https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/api.php?action=feedcontributions&feedformat=atom&user=76.216.0.0%2F16 2026-11-13T22:16:18Z User contributions MediaWiki 1.46.2 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:FlinkyTheStoat/Essay:_On_Villain_Dynamics_in_the_Redwall_Series/@comment-76.216.50.154-20101106165533&diff=34813 2010-11-06T16:55:33Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>We know that BJ's books may be too black-and-whitish because this study is actually really true. I think that, even though I enjoy the books a lot, i would enjoyh them a lot more if BJ diversified the goals and feelings and thoughts of both good and evil creatures. It shouldn't always be &quot;attack redwall for loot or revenge&quot;. And I think I have noticed some hypocracy among the good beasts, like they call vermin that tie them up cowards, and then some of them actually tie prisoners up! Look at Taggerung! He's well known as a hero. And yet he tied Madd up! I do not mean to degrade Tagg. He may be one of my favorite characters, but he is the first example that comes to mind about the whole hypocracy thing.</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Snowpaw_the_Wild/Essay:_Death_in_the_Redwall_Series/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100717191604&diff=30683 2010-07-17T19:16:05Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>And also often with the deaths there is 1 at redwall and another one at somewhere else, but not all in the same place. IE:<br /> Redwall<br /> At Redwall: mortimer/methuselah<br /> Somewhere else: guosim<br /> <br /> MOssflower<br /> At Redwall: mask (sort of, he was in the area)<br /> somewhere else: Boar<br /> <br /> Matimmeo:<br /> at redwall: friar hugo<br /> Somewhere else: warbeak/log a log<br /> <br /> High rhulain<br /> at Redwall: brinty<br /> Somewhere else: pandion/cuthbert frunk (I personally think that one of the otters should have died. I think that kolun should have died.)</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:FlinkyTheStoat/Essay:_On_Villain_Dynamics_in_the_Redwall_Series/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100717190026&diff=30681 2010-07-17T19:00:27Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>i like this analysis very much as well! It's great, the way you systematically treated each book you'd read.</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Ben_the_Claw/How_Verdauga_Died!/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100712003425&diff=30420 2010-07-12T00:34:26Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>hmm. She took a catnap on her sparrow-feather matress; that's funny.</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Baliss/the_councerour/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100712003039&diff=30419 2010-07-12T00:30:43Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>his spelling is bad. remember?</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Baliss/annoying_things_about_redwall/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100712002938&diff=30418 2010-07-12T00:29:40Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>Or the good tacticians are always outsmarted by the Redwallers. I think the vermin general who could keep his conquered fortress the longest was ungatt trunn. And it was salamandastron too. Granted the hares were old and crappy fighters, but who cares about that. After all Bragoon and Saro were probably a little bit younger, but still old, and we got to see Bragoon smash the butts of those 6 reptiles bare-pawed!</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Thornclaw_Braveheart/Redwall%27s_Dealiest_Warrior/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100626162042&diff=29879 2010-06-26T16:20:42Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>There are a bunch of other flinky songs. I like the bath song, and the ferrets are fine old foragers song even more!</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Skipper_Rorc/The_Runaway/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100617100822&diff=29516 2010-06-17T10:08:23Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>up date! Mooooooooooooooore!</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Skipper_Rorc/The_Runaway/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100616141025&diff=29460 2010-06-16T14:10:25Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>how long is this going to be?</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Skipper_Rorc/The_Runaway/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100615184819&diff=29423 2010-06-15T18:48:19Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>Well it looks like we might have some help, MAYBE, if you are luky</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Eulaliaaaa!/Don%27t_Mess_With_Redwall_Abbey/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100614115724&diff=29341 2010-06-14T11:57:25Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>He probably didn't read those.</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Silverfalcon_Pikehawk/Alternate_Martin_the_Warrior/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100614114812&diff=29339 2010-06-14T11:48:13Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>Hm. I don't know</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Thornclaw_Braveheart/Thornclaw%27s_Redwall_Book_Awards/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100614112945&diff=29337 2010-06-14T11:29:45Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>intruiging?</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Skipper_Rorc/The_Runaway/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100609194523&diff=29050 2010-06-09T19:45:23Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>Hmm. Good story as I see it! Hope the rork isn't blinded.</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Thornclaw_Braveheart/Redwall%27s_Dealiest_Warrior/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100530064629&diff=28453 2010-05-30T06:46:29Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>How about Rawback versus Lady Kaltag? They're both crazy, but I bet that Kaltag would win. SHe a cat while he's only a stoat. BUt it would be fun to see</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Thornclaw_Braveheart/Redwall%27s_Dealiest_Warrior/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100521111156&diff=27889 2010-05-21T11:11:56Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>I think you should make the beasts that fight in final battles stronger than they are now because it's final and everything.</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Thornclaw_Braveheart/Redwall%27s_Dealiest_Warrior/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100521105935&diff=27888 2010-05-21T10:59:35Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>Also, we should have another archer contest. How bout doomeye vs lady amber.</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Thornclaw_Braveheart/Redwall%27s_Dealiest_Warrior/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100521013057&diff=27873 2010-05-21T01:30:57Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>Flinky need more songs. Make sure you put the bath song in there.</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Thornclaw_Braveheart/The_Warrior%27s_Aftermath/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100511201944&diff=27397 2010-05-11T20:19:45Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>Oilback can fight someone else. I don't think you should make decisions about who will fight who until all the battles are done. And we should have a limit, say 50 battles, and then we go to the single-elimination finals.</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Martin2/Essay:The_Patterns_of_Redwall_(Rough_Draft)/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100511200316&diff=27393 2010-05-11T20:03:16Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>THe prologue (if the book has one) is always either a poem that kind of references something important in the book say Marlfox, or some old guy from the story telling someone or a group about what happened, as in Salamandastron or the Bellmaker. The epilogue is either a extract from some guy's recording about what happened and how all these new characters are getting along, or a little wrapper-upper if someone is telling other heast the story.</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Galadriadhar/Essay:_Laterose_and_Martin_the_Warrior/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100511194727&diff=27391 2010-05-11T19:47:27Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>Jacques always kills off at laeat one main character in all of his books. Besides Martin and Badrang, Rose was probabbly THE most important character in the book--and a good one to die. In fact in High Rhulain it was kind of lame because the only real character who died was Pandion Piketalon. I think that at least one of the otters from the resistance should have been killed. Maybe Kolun, Deedero, or even Banya.</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Eulaliaaaa!/Kurda_the_Amazingly_Useless_Villainess/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100511193557&diff=27388 2010-05-11T19:35:57Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>Runs and almost pees her pants. Good twist.</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Bluestripe_the_Wild/Vanderdecken%27s_Neutrality/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100511192240&diff=27387 2010-05-11T19:22:40Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>Vanderdecken i bad. He never gave anyone a second chance aboard his ship.</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Dane_the_Wildcat/Good_or_Evil%3F/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100511101457&diff=27349 2010-05-11T10:14:57Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>Well King Bull was just a bit crazy. There were some bad deeds that he did and some OK ones. See he held Matthias captive and fought with him when he saw the sword scabbard being flown down to Jess. But he also fought asmodeus. He is not completely evil. Verdauga. I don't know about him, he is just like this more evil than neutral character, but much better than most villian leaders. He wanted to get Martin the Warrior out of his way, and he taxed the woodlanders for his own purposes, but I believe that the if he had stayed alive, the woodlanders would have been able to persuade him to be a good strong ruler for them. I mean he has the great pontential to be a good ruler. He combines what it takes to be a strong ruler with justice and not as much power-hungry as other villians.</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Raperm/Essay:_Nature_vs._Nurture_in_the_Redwall_Universe/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100511100823&diff=27348 2010-05-11T10:08:23Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>I think that Grubbage was a kind of grayish-white character. Triss never documents anything that Grubbage did tht was bad. He was just this kinda stupid deaf rat. It was only Plugg and his crew that got him into the bad guys. Malbun says that Grubbage is &quot;not at all unlikeable&quot;, and that he is an excellent nav.</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Thornclaw_Braveheart/Redwall%27s_Dealiest_Warrior/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100511095436&diff=27347 2010-05-11T09:54:36Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>Hey, what about say Bragoon the otter vs king sarengo? We know that King Sarengo was a mighty warrior because he could slay Berusca the adder. Tough ferret to beat, unlike his children and grandchildren.</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:FlinkyTheStoat/Essay:The_Grey_Irish_Stoat%3F_Flinky_-_A_Character_Study/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100511011252&diff=27338 2010-05-11T01:12:52Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>I love flinky a lot. His cleverness is just my fav. Another vermin haracter I like with that kind of clever spark in him is Pitru, but Pitru is much much worse than his father. He intentionally killed Jeefra, and he wanted to enslave the otters as they were coming back to their homes after the big final battle. BUt his remarks he made to his father were vicious and funny.</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Verminfate/The_Snake_Hunter_of_Mossflower/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100503195610&diff=27001 2010-05-03T19:56:10Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>Probs the shrew prisoners will make it out or MUggy will fight the snake and kill it?</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Verminfate/Essay:_Redwall%27s_most_controversial_character....._Veil/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100430213853&diff=26854 2010-04-30T21:38:53Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>Veil doesn't deserve all of the stones being thrown at him when people call him purely evil. I believe that, as the bible says, &quot;greater love cannot be shown besides when a man lays his life down for his friend(s)'.</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Verminfate/The_Snake_Hunter_of_Mossflower/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100430103527&diff=26831 2010-04-30T10:35:27Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>And the snake armor plates at the same time :d</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Verminfate/The_Snake_Hunter_of_Mossflower/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100429212016&diff=26802 2010-04-29T21:20:16Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>Hmm. Well I think that the same thing will happen to poor redgo if the shrews try anything, so be careful</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Verminfate/The_Snake_Hunter_of_Mossflower/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100426062529&diff=26624 2010-04-26T06:25:29Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>Zimla will be a traitor, I know it, I KNOW IT ...</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Verminfate/The_Snake_Hunter_of_Mossflower/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100424235923&diff=26499 2010-04-24T23:59:23Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>Well I am pretty sure Redjaw's gone for good ...</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Verminfate/The_Snake_Hunter_of_Mossflower/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100424095524&diff=26468 2010-04-24T09:55:24Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>hah! Like it lot ..</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Verminfate/The_Adventures_of_Badrang_and_Badredd/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100420085651&diff=26154 2010-04-20T08:56:51Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>Have you gotten writer's block, or are you doing other stuff?</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Verminfate/The_Adventures_of_Badrang_and_Badredd/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100412191459&diff=25608 2010-04-12T19:15:00Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>badr ...</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Verminfate/The_Adventures_of_Badrang_and_Badredd/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100412113001&diff=25585 2010-04-12T11:30:01Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>Haha, Skrodd! I'd love to hear it: &quot;GIVE ME BACK MY CUTLASS YOU RUNT!&quot;!!</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Verminfate/The_Adventures_of_Badrang_and_Badredd/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100411223604&diff=25547 2010-04-11T22:36:04Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>Mebbe the dillypins will be poofed into like the Blackrobes and killed! Twould change what Tagg and Nimbalo saw, eh</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Verminfate/The_Adventures_of_Badrang_and_Badredd/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100410145819&diff=25431 2010-04-10T14:58:19Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>Why did that phantom badger guy just appear on the Volcano island. and, &quot;Hey, lok behind you, they're hunting an endangered species!&quot; And they all run away, it's like, they're dummies, or something, lol, I love this story, It's FUNNY!</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Verminfate/The_Adventures_of_Badrang_and_Badredd/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100410144609&diff=25428 2010-04-10T14:46:09Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>iF MEMORY SERVES, THE tAGGERUNG VERMIN WHO GOT slung by them werer bad off. Make sure you put in Great-autn Lollery's ancestor!</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Verminfate/The_Adventures_of_Badrang_and_Badredd/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100410004119&diff=25411 2010-04-10T00:41:19Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>OH yeah! FUN! SLingo!</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Verminfate/The_Adventures_of_Badrang_and_Badredd/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100409150644&diff=25388 2010-04-09T15:06:44Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>DOn't know about wiki idea! Liked the part where Badredd is just like, &quot;YOu go get me some food&quot;! and they go get him some food. Where is ch10 gonna go anyway?</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Verminfate/The_Adventures_of_Badrang_and_Badredd/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100407224833&diff=25293 2010-04-07T22:48:33Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>Probs will land in the Blackrobes or part of Slagar's gang.</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Verminfate/The_Adventures_of_Badrang_and_Badredd/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100406233247&diff=25208 2010-04-06T23:32:47Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>gruntan Kurdly, and Tantail make fun of him, haha, put dem in the camp of Stringle ... haha!!! Poof into Tsarmina's palace when they bump into Gonff, aw man, that would be funny!!! MOreerrreeeeeeeeeee@</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Verminfate/The_Snake_Hunter_of_Mossflower/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100307203457&diff=23693 2010-03-07T20:34:58Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>I think that all the books after Triss could've taken place in any order you please, but that's me.</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Verminfate/The_Darkblades/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100215003421&diff=22614 2010-02-15T00:34:21Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>Yay!!!! Redwall won!!!!!!! Now, for BB!</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Verminfate/The_Darkblades/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100214180509&diff=22573 2010-02-14T18:05:09Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>What's hegs?</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Verminfate/The_Darkblades/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100214085006&diff=22560 2010-02-14T08:50:06Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>Cool! What about BOrskin? I mean he's dead, and Skipper, in the swamp.</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Verminfate/The_Darkblades/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100213213825&diff=22516 2010-02-13T21:38:25Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>I'd kill Wengal! By the way, what about Adventures of Badredd and Badgrang? That's so FUNNY!</div>

76.216.50.154 https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Verminfate/The_Darkblades/@comment-76.216.50.154-20100212210758&diff=22458 2010-02-12T21:07:58Z

<p>76.216.50.154: started new page.</p> <hr /> <div>Fun how Borskin die. Hope more good guy die! HOpe Bloodskull has more fun!</div>

76.216.50.154