imported>LordTBT: started new page.

2008-06-22T05:57:55Z

started new page.

New page

{{essay|LordTBT}}

:''Note: This essay is a response to [[Essay:Asmodeus' Neutrality]]''

[[Asmodeus]] is by no means a neutral character in the ''Redwall'' saga, an innocent
victim by which the woodlanders project their thoughts and fears. If "neutral" is
to suggest that he neither sides with the Redwallers or [[Cluny the Scourge]],
than this is accurate, however to suggest that Asmodeus is neutral in the sense
that he is neither good nor evil is patently false.

With the first introduction of the snake, [[Brian Jacques|Jacques]] describes him
as "the most evil-looking adder that had ever been born".

Cluny the Scourge, not understanding the significance of the creature's name
after [[Ragear]]'s death, is enlightened by [[Killconey]], who incredulously states:

''"Tis the dreaded name of the divvil himself."''

And Killconey is correct - the name comes [[Wikipedia:Asmodai|directly from the Bible]],
in which Asmodeus is a vengeful, slaughtering demon. Naming a seemingly evil character
after another is certainly not a coincidence, especially given Jacques' well-known
naming conventions.

Later, Asmodeus is referred to as the "slivering evil", and having "evil poisoned fangs".

However it is first [[Matthias]], and soon thereafter [[Martin the Warrior]], who calls the
snake the "evil one".

But let's discuss the traits of Asmodeus:

*Indiscriminate killing of vermin and goodbeasts by devouring or hypnotizing

*Collection of trinkets from victims

*Accumulation of attractive objects that are not his property

Absolutely no aspect of the snake could be described as good, not to mention
the fact that [[Berussca|every]] [[Zassaliss|single]] [[Harssacss|snake]] [[Sesstra|that]]
[[Deathcoil|appears]] [[Reptiles of Marshwood Hill|in the ''Redwall'' saga]] just so
happens to be a villain!

Matthias did not kill Asmodeus in order to retrieve the [[Sword of Martin]], nor did he kill Asmodeus because he was somehow interfering in the battle against Cluny. Matthias slew the adder purely because his own life was at stake, plain and simple.

===On Medieval Dragons===

The comparison of Asmodeus to [[Wikipedia:European_dragon#Dragons_in_Germanic_mythology|medieval dragons]]
is quite accurate - however not in the sense that they were neutral.

The theft and hoarding of treasure, residency in an underground lair, and forced
captivity and slaughter of innocents are all applicable aspects.

Thus, Asmodeus can certainly be ascertained to be a villainous character, and not some sort of neutral bystander.

[[Category:Essays]]

Essay:Asmodeus' Neutrality:A Rebuttal - Revision history

imported>LordTBT: started new page.