imported>LordTBT at 22:03, 13 May 2025

2025-05-13T22:03:56Z

New page

I have a question pertaining to all Tribes books. I put it here because this is the newest one at this point.

My question:
Why make these? They will be made pretty much obsolete by the first new book in the series that comes after them. What about five years after? It would be pretty much pointless to buy them then. Take the Tribes of Redwall: Badgers. It came out in 2001. It is now 2006, almost 2007. How many new Badgers have been introduced since it came out? Now, I am not being critical of BJ or of Redwall or anyone else. I love the series. It is my absolute favorite series. I am just being what I consider practical. ToR: Badgers, Otters, and Mice are pretty much out of date now with 3-5 new book out since they were published. Is Brian Jaques planning on coming out with updated ones at any point in time? In my opinion, he should come out with new editions or whatever maybe every 5-10 books. If they want to keep them up to date that is. What do you think? Criticize me if you wish. I don't mind. In fact, if someone did point out a flaw or three in my argument (for lack of a better term), I would be more than delighted to read it. Thanks for taking the time to read this. Always A Devoted Redwall Fan, [[User:Gortarzis|Gortarzis]] 01:28, 14 October 2006 (UTC) Sorry for the repeated saves when I made no changes. My browser was slow, then shut down. When I got it back up, I opened it up right into the edit page and just saved it again without checking.

:Seeing as nobody on this site is quite official, my answer will be speculation and logic. First off: Why make these? The fact that they are obsolete doesn't mean that we shouldn't make them. We make Guiness Books every year, though they will become obsolete. They will always become obsolete at one time or another until BJ dies/retires. Is BJ planning on coming out with updated ones? Well, I really don't know... Check the [http://www.redwall.net/ official site] for info on that. Publishing four new books with only fairly minor changes would certainly not be profitable, and thus it will not happen.

:P.S. Although we're all flattered by the fact that you're asking us questions about this, this site is not a discussion forum. I would recommend the Long Patrol, or another forum, for discussions like this, if you'll excuse me for being abrupt. --[[User:Docbob|Docbob]] 23:13, 15 October 2006 (UTC)

== Incomplete Articles ==

Is this really incomplete, since there is not really much more to say? Should the category be removed from this page? Or is the category useless altogether, just a second ''stubs''? For those of you with not clue what I am saying, [[:Category:Incomplete articles|see here]]. [[User:The Fivemole|The Fivemole]] [[Image:Grumm.jpg|60px]] [[Message_Wall:The Fivemole|Burr Aye, Gurt Zurrs!!]] 01:13, May 25, 2012 (UTC)

Talk:Tribes of Redwall Squirrels - Revision history

imported>LordTBT at 22:03, 13 May 2025