Jump to content

Welcome to the Redwall Wiki, your communal Redwall and Brian Jacques information resource! Free registration eliminates the ads!

User blog comment:Martin2/Essay:Unanswered Questions of Redwall (Rebuttal)/@comment-1479469-20100130074816

From the Redwall Wiki Clone, your Redwall news and information resource.
Revision as of 08:00, 30 January 2010 by imported>D2r
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)

Countering your rebuttal:

1. It's not just the fact that there's no mention of wheat fields: it's that there is basically no place on the map where they could exist. There aren't any areas large enough for the wheat fields that would be required to produce that much bread. Even if we assume they're off the map, such an explanation runs into the "how is trade performed without extant trade routes" issue.

And besides; the "not mentioned/taken for granted" defence isn't really valid: these problems arise precisely because they are unanswered or left to the reader to figure out. I mean, the whole point of a plot hole is that it's something the author's left unaddressed, right? So you can't really defend it by saying that the author not providing an answer constitutes the necessary existence of a canonical answer...

2. I'll grant the points on Salamandastron and Southsward, but where do they get the iron and steel? Come to think of it, where do they get the feathers for fletching without killing birds for them? As for the hordes...there's no mention of the forges, so we can't just assume a priori that they're there. Leaving aside the huge logistical issues inherent in keeping a portable blacksmith and his requisite supplies in a horde, they're never mentioned at any point in the novels, so it's impossible to simply assume that without it being simple conjecture rather than a cohesive answer....