Jump to content

Welcome to the Redwall Wiki, your communal Redwall and Brian Jacques information resource! Free registration eliminates the ads!

User blog comment:Martin2/Essay:Is Madd from Taggerung Fwirl's dead mother?(Rebuttal)/@comment-24.136.170.154-20100213002408

From the Redwall Wiki Clone, your Redwall news and information resource.
Revision as of 00:24, 13 February 2010 by 24.136.170.154 (Talk) (started new page.)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)

Hmm a few issues with this. I will list them by the numbers. 1 and 2: Yes, a coincidence is possible but I think the author would have realized this. 4: it never said the log had holes. 5: true, but lying very still could mean unconscious as well. 6: If Madd had a deep head wound and was lying very still, how would they have known? Vermin aren't known for being very bright. Yes, foxes are generally smarter but if they have a nice strong squirrel slave, why check one that looks dead? Last point, Brian Jacques never said she was... but he never said she wasn't. 

In any event, you made some good points. Well done.
Retrieved from "https://redwallwiki.otterobservatory.com/index.php?title=User_blog_comment:Martin2/Essay:Is_Madd_from_Taggerung_Fwirl%27s_dead_mother%3F(Rebuttal)/@comment-24.136.170.154-20100213002408&oldid=22465"