User blog comment:D2r/Unanswered Questions of Redwall/@comment-3518397-20110411191411/@comment-1479469-20110422233522
Appearance
I'm hesitant to include the mine in the first book - it has its own continuity problems (e.g. Cluny being Portuguese, the presence of dogs and the horse, the cart), so I dunno if that works, especially since the mines are never mentioned again. As for the Redwall forge - well, okay, that solves cutlery. But even so - who's producing the other weapons?
EDIT: Since Redwall has a forge, I scratched out 2a, although it's still unclear where Salamandastron and the others get THEIR metal implements, as well as who manufactures all the weapons (since Redwall doesn't seem to be into weapons export). Congratulations!