User:SaynaSLuke/Comments and Critiques

I decided to make this page cause there's a lot of great stories out there on RW that aren't getting enough comments, and I feel unable to comment a lot of the time. But I know how important it is to a writer's inspiration to get feedback, believe me, I know. The first half of FWC I wrote with very few comments, and it was like dragging a sack of rocks up a steep hill .. to be honest. I'm an extremely stubborn person, that's why I didn't give up XD But I want to offer help to all my friends, lately, I just feel buried in a pile of schoolwork, 4H projects, and archery. However, I've devised I way that I will be able to comment/critique more often, so yay! :D

Ok, here's the deal. If you want feedback (and Astar, Lus, I'll probably do yours anyway. But sometimes I need reminded on everything else ..) put your siggy and what kind of feedback you'd like at the bottom of this page. Also, which story you'd like it on :)

If you want a comment, I'll just encourage you/tell you what I like about the story. It probably won't be super long, just a little something. But then it might get long depending on how much you have written ;)

However, if you really want to know exactly what I'm thinking, that's when you ask for a critique. Critiques are very helpful to an author, and often helpful to the one critiquing. In a critique, I'll first .

1. Tell you want I do like about story/chapter

2. Tell you things that didn't feel quite right/might need improved upon

3. Point out random things

4. And again probably tell you something that I like

It's not something to be afraid of, it's just sometimes people would rather not have a critique. And since critiques take longer, I'll probably critique per chapter. (I do this on the other site I'm on, OYAN, so I do have a bit of practice)

Anyway. I'll probably do a few of these a week. I just don't always know which story to do first, and this will help that.