User blog comment:D2r/Unanswered Questions of Redwall/@comment-1479469-20100131050149
@ Wildfin:
5. Even if I accept that explanation (which still strikes me as begging the question as to how they obtain food), that doesn't explain where all the weapons come from. You need foundries and forges (not to say mines for getting the metal in the first place) to make the number you see in the books, not to mention anchors, cutlery, what have you - none of that's mentioned. And as for Redwall being self-sufficient - granted, but where do they farm the food from to get it in such quantities?
9. Granted, but with the casualty levels they take you think the population wouldn't be able to reproduce...
11. To be frank, this was a gag entry at best. This being said, you'd think they'd want an heir if they're trying to take over Southsward. For the record, by the way, Foxwolf was probably the most successful villian (barring Verdauga, who was undefeated militarily and had to be poisoned), since he actually did manage to take and hold his objective for over a couple of hours.